Episode 16: Unexpected

Sorry for the delay in getting this week’s blog up. We were shut down for President’s day and I didn’t have the tech support I needed to get the blog online. (i.e. I have a very limited knowledge of computers and I need my awesome assistant Erin to actually do anything.)


AWESOME ASSISTANT ERIN

OK – last night’s episode was one that I directed, which invariably means that I have more to say about it.

First of all, this is the one split episode that every TV show does each season. This means that we prepped the episode in late December, then took a two-week vacation, and then came back shooting. Historically, on whatever show I’m on, this episode is one that I, as the show’s producer, frequently take on, because it’s hard on any other director. In late December the crew is tired, everyone is really ready for their Christmas break, and the prep is frequently kind of sketchy. Jim Chory, the line producer and I, joked about how there are several days back in December that we don’t even remember.

Then, to make matters worse everyone goes and rests and forgets all about the show, and then, with no days of additional prep – we all just come back and start shooting. I took this episode on because I’m pretty good at rolling with the punches and thinking on my feet. And, because I know the show so well, I can compensate for anything that slips between the cracks.

HEROES is a real tricky show as a director, because there are so many different stories going at once, and because each story has it’s own unique visual style, pace and performance style. It’s hard enough to grasp the different styles, if you don’t also plan how the styles will integrate together you can end up with an episode that feels vaguely erratic. I don’t knit, but I imagine it’s like knitting a sweater with a number of different types of wools and thread pattern. You have to carefully plan what you’re going to do ahead of time and then make sure you’re executing it in the moment.

Maybe the thing to do is to just talk through a few scenes and talk about what I was going for stylistically and in terms of performance.

First of all, I’m very happy with the whole Peter/Claude/Isaac storyline. My whole directorial style is to try to first glean (a) which character controls the scene – sometimes it shifts within a scene (b) what is the inherent emotional quality of the scene – meaning, both, what do the characters feel and what do I want the audience to feel? – sometimes they’re the same, sometimes they’re different. (c) what stylistic techniques – i.e. what colors, compositions, camera movement and camera lensing – will support these emotions. I wanted the Peter/Claude – Peter/Isaac storyline to have a uniform quality, an inherent tension. I’d been noticing that handheld really works for us. I’d done a lot on my episode 6, less so on episode 9. I consciously chose to do most of this storyline handheld.

In the first scene with HRG and Isaac, HRG is in control of the scene. So in that one I used cranes and dollys and let the shots sweep and push in. Trying to visually mimic the emotion of the scene – pressure. The pressure HRG is putting on Isaac. After that, there’s a scene on the roof with Claude and Milo, where Claude beats the hell out of Peter with a Bo Stick. In this almost every shot is handheld and the camera trades off from character to character a lot. This technique adds a sense of chaos and unbalance - and whenever I cut wide to show the special relationship’s (important to do so your audience doesn’t get completely disoriented) I used big sweeping wide shots done from a crane, which are always passing over foreground objects. Moving past close foreground on full figure shots adds both a sense of speed and a sense of pressure.

In the second rooftop scene, the one at night (which begins with Claude and Peter and then shifts to their being attacked by HRG and The Haitian), I began the scenes on the dolly, with lyrical dolly shots. The first shot is a longish dolly shot which begins on a pigeon, drifts across the birdcage into a two shot of Peter and Claude and then pushes in. There was no coverage (i.e. other shots to cut to) until Claude turns and says, “I think he meant you friend." Eccleston came to me before the scene and expressed that he thought it was important on that one line to express a softening in his character. That he’s beginning to like and be impressed with Peter. I agreed and supported this with gently moving shots. When HRG appears all the angles on Claude and Peter go to handheld – but the ones on HRG and Haitian are stable – on the dolly. I particularly love the wide wide shot where Peter jumps off the edge of the building. Our set is a huge set on a blue screen stage. I shot it as wide as I could and the VFX people at Stargate added a background building extension and New York backdrop. It’s so cool. It’s a quick cut, but it looks like Peter just jumps off the building and drops into nowhere.

The flying shots I had actually shot way back in December, at the same time as we had done shots for Peter being thrown off the roof for episode 14. I’ve done flying before, on SMALLVILLE. There’s a sequence in the season premiere of season 4, when Clark flies into the air, out onto the edge of space and up to Lex Luthor’s jet. I thought that was pretty good TV! But trust me flying is hard too do right. You have to hang the actors in uncomfortable positions on a huge blue screen stage and blow giant wind-fans at them, then you have to swoop the camera around them to mimic their flight through the air. The hours fly by as you have lots of discussions about “tilt” and “yaw” while the actors are getting angrier and angrier because their testicles are being crushed by the harness they’re in. It’s not that fun. I’m pretty happy with the way Peter’s flight turned out – but I don’t think it’s 100% brilliant or groundbreaking. I tell you this is a really hard thing to do right. Next time I’ll do better.

I’m very happy with the scene in Peter’s apartment where Claude wakes up, gets all paranoid and runs out. This scene, to me, was driven by Claude. Claude is scared – a state we’ve never seen him in. He knows he’s in danger. Peter is confused. I wanted to support this emotion, again by going handheld and also by dropping back and shooting with long lenses through windows and French doors – long lenses compress the filmed image and this created tension and a sense of “surveillance” – like they might be being watched. I alternated this by doing super close close-ups on relatively wide 40mm lenses. Alternating between long lens full shots and wide lens close ups is sort of the opposite way from the traditional. It gives the scene an unbalanced “afraid” feeling.


MILO ON A VIDEO MONITOR


CHRIS ECCLESTON – FIXIN’ TO FLY


MILO AND CHRIS – LEARN TO FLY


MILO AND CHRIS – LIKE A FREE BIRD

I’m pretty happy with the Suresh/Sylar story as well. First of all I think these two actors are terrific together. Zack Quinto was amazing at shifting between the mild mannered character of Zane and the frightful Sylar. The gust star Rusty Schwimmer was great and brought great empathy to her character in just 2 short scenes. I got a little experimental in these scenes and with, in my opinion, some but not complete success.

Again I went hand held for a lot of the firsts scene when the two guys arrive at the car repair shop. The first phase of that scene, for me, was about general movement – Mohinder controls the scene – but he’s not completely “in” control of the result. In this part I made the camera move handheld on a relatively long shot that tracks them in, playing a fair bit of dialogue on their backs. Being on backs when people are talking creates a sense of discomfort in the audience. You have to be careful with it, because it can also alienate the audience from the characters – so you have to do it at the right time. As the scene progresses Sylar begins to take over. Here I began to use a “swing and tilt” lens on many of the close-ups. The swing and tilt is a lens that was invented for architectural photography – to photograph buildings and keep the whole surface of a building in focus. With most lenses the plane of focus is flat. With these lenses the plane of focus can be shifted to the diagonal, either up and down or side to side. So, as Rusty’s character began to tell her story, and Sylar gets excited about obtaining her power – I used these lenses in his close up and her close up – but not on Suresh’s CU. To the audience the close ups look “weird” kind of in focus, kind of not – but now what we’re normally used to seeing. Again – it’s uncomfortable. I’ve been using these lenses a lot on HEROES, but not so aggressively in a place where you would normally use a traditional lens – like this scene. At the end of the day I feel it’s only a partial success. The shots are a bit too self-conscious. And, because we’re in traditional coverage, we cut back to them several times, which makes them call attention to themselves more than I’d like. Next time I’ll back off this technique or use it AND get a regular shot – so the weird ones can be used more judiciously.

Later, however, I used the same technique to good effect. In the scene where Sylar comes to kill Dale, I used one swing and tilt lenses on one shot on her close up when she says, “What’s that sound in your heart.” And again in the close up where he says “murder.” Once more, the shots feel weird and the plane of focus is not what we’re used to. But because each shot is used just once or twice the technique doesn’t become so apparent – and it works better.

All the scenes in the Bennett storyline I’m quite happy with as well. Claire’s scenes tend to be driven by Claire. She is always fighting for understanding and stability. I tend to be more stable with the camera in Claire’s story. Not moving the camera or moving it slowly and menacingly. In the scene where she nervously tells her mother not to trust Dad, for instance, the camera was always static… But I alternated between big wide shots where Claire and her mother were on opposite sides of the frame and the couch and coffee table dominated the foreground. I shot Mrs. Bennett’s close ups traditionally and shot Claire’s shots either super-tight, or off-center with uncomfortably little room on the leading edge of the frame – all designed to create a sense of discomfort. Because the camera’s never moving, the pace of editing determines the rhythm of the scene. In the mother’s speeches we tended to stay in one shot. In Claire’s speeches we tended to jump from one Claire close-up to another. Again this adds a sense of disquiet and tension.

The scene in the hospital with Claire and her father is one of my favorite scenes I’ve done on the show. I did nothing fancy besides shoot two close ups… But Jack and Hayden were awesome. On a performance level I talked d to Jack about the idea of losing control. That this is the first time in the show we’ve seen a chink in the armor. . I think he played that wonderfully. I particularly love his expression when he thinks that, once again, he’s been able to win her over and she suddenly shouts “No!” and pushes him back. Sometimes in my job it’s about style. Sometimes the most appropriate style is to get out of the way and let the actors and the script do their thing.

If there’s any area I’m not as happy about it’s a couple of the Hiro/Ando scenes. Typically I shoot Hiro’s story framed a bit wider and more traditionally... i.e. in a more comedic style. I think I let the comedy get away from me on this one. It’s the first time I’ve had a situation where there were other characters who were meant to be comedic besides Hiro. At least that was my interpretation of what Hope and Gustavson’s roles were intended to be. Specifically, there is the big shootout scene. Jeph Loeb kept telling me that they didn’t want it to be about the gunfire or cars blowing up. Frankly, I was confused. I think I sort of nodded and “yeah, yeah, yeahed….” But I’m not sure I ever got what he was saying. I mean, the two characters were shooting at each other for a page of dialogue. So I photographed the scene, figuring we can either choose to see or not see the gunfire in editing. By the way that kind of work is hard. It was two all-night shoots. It was freezing cold. And it takes a long time to set up shots between explosions. I was off my game in that I didn’t have my own strong point of view about the scene… I kept thinking about the what-not-to-do instead of the what-to-do. In the end I feel disappointed with myself. I don’t feel like I found a way into these scenes that was special or especially well planned like the others I’ve been describing. I feel I did let the comedy get a little too big I’m not sure how you, the fans, felt… But I know that I have a sense of not having completely succeeded here and it’s makes my stomach turn in knots and has for weeks. But, in reflection, I’m not 100% sure what I would have done differently…

Actually, the last Hiro and Ando scene I really like. The one where Hiro says goodbye and gets on the bus. I think Masi and James did a very nice job and the scene feels melancholy in a good way. Also, when Hiro gets on the bus, the bus driver is played by Stan Lee… Stan Lee! The guy who invented Spiderman, The Fantastic Four and the X-Men!!! How cool is that. He’s like the funniest nicest guy too.

That’s it for now. Next week we blow up West Texas and see how it all began for Claire and HRG!

See you then!


JEPH LOEB AND I


SANTIAGO CABRERA AND I


MILO, SANTIAGO AND A PAINTING OF MILO


MASI, STAN LEE AND JEPH LOEB


MASI AND STAN LEE HAMMING IT UP FOR THE PRESS


ASSISTANT DIRECTOR TONY ADLER CONTEMPLATES LIFE AND DEATH

Comments

Anonymous said…
Hi there, and thanks for this great blog! I just want to say that the scene with Milo and Chris fighting with the Bo Stick was gobsmacking brilliant! These two have great 'duo' chemistry, and I really hope Chris will be on the show for a while!

Great comments about the filming (this does not go unnoticed). The scenes at the top of the blue screened Deveaux building and the CGI are truly magnificent.

Thanks,
Robbie in So Cal

One more thing...I had to console a male co-worker today because he was all worked up about Sylar's evilness. Hehe. Great job to all!
I agree with you on every point in regards to your directing of this episode, Greg. There were places where you went wrong, made some bad choices, and it was painfully obvious. Those weirdly distorted and out of focus scenes at the car repair shop were just...well, I kept thinking, "Why didn't they reshoot this? It's horrible and never should have made it to air."

But just as you noted in your blog post, there were other things you executed beautifully and with masterful precision in this ep. That scene in the hospital between Claire and her dad, for instance. Fan-friken-tastic. The flying scenes with Milo (my future boy toy) and Chris (the Best. Doctor. Evar.)...great job on those two.

One thing I'd like to mention about the acting in this ep, in particular, the hospital scene with Jack and Hayden. Comparisons have been made between the characters of HRG and Cancer Man/CSM from the X-Files. I really appreciated Bill Davis's work in that role (note to self: hire him for The Black Tower) and I remember, I guess it was in season 4 or 5, where the icy-cool CSM had his very first public freakout (with Mulder, I think it was). Bill played the scene with an edge of fear and panic in his voice. Very unsettling to see a character who always plays it so cool, so close to the vest, have a meldown, even if just for a moment. I saw that same kind of reaction in HRG in this ep. Jack did a fantastic job. Please tell him I said so, Greg.

KJC
Anonymous said…
Thanks again for involving us in the Heroes process. There is, however, one thing that bothered me in this episode. When Chris and Milo were flying, Chris is slumped over Milo like an unconscious sack of potatoes. We don't really get to see him react, or maybe I just missed this. Great job with the Sylar shots though. I totally imagined him drooling as Dale explained her power.
Anonymous said…
The directing in this show is really stellar, and it shows through. Most people take cinematography and camera work for granted, but reading your blog each week has definitely made me start noticing how each director does his or her own thing.

I particularly thought the scenes with Sylar and Mohinder had a really cool feel to them, and the close up on Sylar when he said 'murder' was downright chilling.

Thanks for including the fans in the behind-the-scenes stuff on the show. I am officially now watching Heroes instead of 24 on Monday nights! ~Pete
travis blanston said…
The way you speak openly and honestly of your work is admirable, expressing pride and self-criticism within the same paragraphs. There are of course many other things present. Open-mindedness. Concern. It is probably too obvious fruitless to list them all. I don't mean to sound rhetorical and dramatic. It's something that I enjoy having the opportunity to appreciate - the conscious engine behind a creation. Too often that consciousness is faceless and anonymous.

If the goal in creating a work, such as a TV series, or a record, or a book is to communicate with your peers, the blog adds a very nice and personal touch.

You demonstrate the desire to excel in your craft well enough simply by viewing the episodes. To read your afterthoughts, to me, really just seals the deal. Thank you for sharing this here.
nabeel said…
Fantastic episode! Last week's, though interesting, was a bit of a lull progress-wise. "Unexpected" was return back to form. This week's blog post was also a fascinating read, thanks a lot!
Anonymous said…
The best episode so far , well done Mr Beeman!!!

The Milo Chris scenes were electric, I was on the edge of my seat for everyone of them, the Bo stick fight, the flight, the paranoid fear frenzy of Claude's

And IMO Milo is becoming one of the best character actors on the show, he really is changing covincingly.I love his scenes.I love Zach's scenes too...and thanks for explaining the slight off focus camera effect, it was like looking at them close up from inside a goldfish bowl

The Isaac/Peter scene at the end was so brilliantly intense, and the spinning around Isaac as he's swishing the gun around was incredible

And you really captured the amazing Bennets so well...poor HRG and poor baby Claire. I cannot wait for next week

Thanks again so much, you guys have created the best show for me since the X Files!!!
Jacki said…
This blog is just fantastic. It amazes me that you devote so much time to explaining the creative process for the fans! I absolutely love the insight. This is certainly one of my favorite must-read blogs!

I noticed in this episode that some of the scenes seemed to have a prominent lighting color (like one of the rooftops scenes was mostly green if I remember correctly). How do you decide what color to use? Is it based on the emotions of the scene, or the characters?
Anonymous said…
I couldn't wait to read your blog to find out how you created that "weird" effect during the Sylar/Dale scenes. It created just the right amount of menace and foreboding.

I think you're being too hard on yourself about the shootout scene. It was funny, but it didn't go too far. As a viewer, I could appreciate the danger that Hiro and Ando were in, so it didn't seem out of place when the gun was suddenly turned on them.

This was the best episode of the season, and I can't wait for next week.
Anonymous said…
Whoa, Overloaded with Camera Techniques :) (yay! I can use some of your skills thanks :) )

Anyways, Beeman, you Rock!
Some of the shots I feel was weird though, but it's more because of editing and not really the shot itself. (About continuity and how the scene flows).

At the end of the day, GREAT JOB :)
Anonymous said…
Oh, Beeman...

Pleaaassse tell us that Chris is coming back, sometime. He's been a joy to watch. His scenes with Mil have been wonderful...but I'd love to see Claude interact with HRG!
Anonymous said…
And I just thought the welder scenes were fuzzy because it's a friken cold bright day in Bozeman. It shows that I don't understand how sea-level people think--I thought the shot worked.

AH
Colorado
Anonymous said…
Best episode yet.
The Heroes-fan community here in Finland(!) seem to think so too.

Great action scenes, stellar "darkness" with Peter's character as he's talking with Isaac (i thought he would kill him Sylar-style, and that it would have resulted in Isaac's death we saw in ep.2 -- there was the gun and all...), and Claire's scenes have always been one of my favorites. Full of power and feeling.

Absolutely great work!
Anonymous said…
For me the shoot-out scene worked because it was about our "heroes" and not about the actual shoot out. The shoot-out was more of a setting than the actual focus of the scene. It worked.
Anonymous said…
Heya,

It always amuses me how many different ways and with how many different kinds of equipment a single scene can be shot. Even though I'm usually too excited for a new episode to pay much attention to the opening credits, I could tell this was one of yours. Very interesting and entertaining. As for the Hope/Gustavson shoot-out, sometimes it's funnier to leave things to the imagination than to show exactly what's going on. I'm not sure if that's what you meant when talking about whether or not to show the actual fight or not, but in the end, the story isn't about anyone other than Hiro and Ando so keeping focus on them makes sense. I liked their reaction to that unusually large explosion. There's also a question swimming around my brain about whether Hiro can compartmentalize his power b/c Ando remembered being shot at and asked what happened. Also, he didn't really reverse all time as the bullet wouldn't have gone back into the gun with force enough to throw her arm aside. She would have just walked backwards out of view again, no? Yes, this is what a fangirl does with her time—thinks about the minutae until her head goes asplodey.
Thanks for another great episode!
Anonymous said…
Hello and thanks from a big fan! I enjoy learning some of the craft behind the scenes as well as watching the show, your blog is great! Kudos for you and all you work with on creating what really looks fantastic pretty much all the time!

I think you're being too hard on yourself on the shootout scene, everyone is their own worse critic, right? I found it great to watch those two giants battle it out A-Team style, and it added to the comedy a lot of fans expect when Hiro and Ando are on screen together. Now if we ever see Matt or Hana running through open space shooting from the hip you can be sure to hear about it but I think you're doing a great job creating the proper scenes for all the characters, really.

Keep up the enthusiasm and great work, we'll keep watching and reading!
RosieBoo said…
I thought the Hiro/Ando scene was fine. I was aware, enough, that this shootout was going on, but more concerned with the fate of our hero team. Hiro using his powers unknowingly made me forget the shootout. :)

Thanks for this blog...it's amazing! And, I caught you on the NBC Rewind commentary of this episode...but, the first act just keeps replaying through the whole episode. That happened last week. Just wanted to give someone a heads up!

I love love love the show! And, probably the only human on earth that loves Sylar. I think I really love Zach because I know what an actor he is to pull off that character. I sure hope he doesn't go ka-blooey at the season's end...
Anonymous said…
i am so happy for you guys! THIS IS PROBABLY my favorite episode...

probably b'coz Milo is the main hero... can't wait for the Sylar and Milo battle which is going to be spectacular. the writting was so much cleaner and tied everything beautifullly together... i love Jeph Loeb's style of writting... great choice

well i'll read your blog next week :)
Anonymous said…
I LOVED the Hir/Ando/Gun fight scene at the end of the episode. I felt a real sense of danger during the whole shoot out. It was very "real" to me.

And i LOVE the drama that takes place in the Claire storyline.

I LOVE 'HEROES'!
Ladyvina said…
Hi, Greg! I just wanted you to know that there is a blog posted by a Spanish director, Alex de la Iglesia (El crímen Ferpecto, La comunidad, 800 Balas, El día de la Bestia) Now he is shooting "Oxford Murders" in London starring Elijah Wood and John Hurt. You should see the blog although most of it is in Spanish but at least you will enjoy the pictures as much as I enjoyed yours.
Congrats on Heroes. I am getting to know about it.
Ladyvina said…
Sorry the address to the blog is
www.blasfemandoenelvrticedeluniverso.blogspot.com
Anonymous said…
Great episode! The developments in the Peter and Bennet stories were great and I agree that Mohinder and Sylar have fantastic chemistry together. My one disappointment, I must say, is that Nathan continues to get minimal airtime and very little focus on his character. It's unfortunate, because I think Adrian Pasdar/Nathan should be on the same level as Peter, Niki, Claire and Hiro in terms of airtime and character development. And yet he hasn't had more than a handful scenes that are actually about him and not his brother. I hope that changes soon...

I thought the final scene was just beautifully shot and I'm hoping we see a lot of fallout, because this is absolutely huge for both Peter and Isaac.
kevbayer said…
I loved the gunfight going on "behind" and practically off-camera from Hiro and Ando. I thought it really expressed their displacement in events going on around them. The comedy was well-played too. Great scripting.
Anonymous said…
Hello MR.Beeman. Greetings from two Spanish fans! Now it’s a week since a wonderful day: last Thursday “Heroes” arrived to Spain. So we have decided to write you. First of all, we have to tell you that the pilot made an incredible share. The channel that aired it, grew from a share of a three percent (Thu, February 8th, 22:00 to 23:00), to a twelve percent!!!!!! (Thu, February 15th, 22:00 to 23:00).

Thank God Internet exists, cause we’re super fans and we really like reading your blog, especially things about making off, directors and actors. And, thanks to Internet, we can follow the series at the same time US viewers do. It is incredible how each character is likable in one or another way (Sylar is one of the most magnetic villains that has ever existed- Magneto aside). We can’t wait to buy the DVD with the extras and commentaries!! We both are cinema students, and hope work in that, but... really, Heroes is cinema, and good cinema. We are astonished by the quality of the TV shows you have in US.

But we have to complain about one thing... we want a Spanish hero!!!! (lol!) We watched carefully Mohinder’s map, and there seems to be one just at Madrid. By the way... have you considered creating an spin-off... perhaps something like “Heroes: Europe”? As with “West Coast Avengers”. And... would you need people to work on it? Ahem...

Ok, more seriously... thank you again for the show, for your blog, for all the cast and crew’s excellent work. If you want, we will keep you informed about the Spanish airing’s share.

Oh, one last thing... we are so shoked by what happened to Simone in the last episode... was who we saw a Darth Petrelli? Will it last for long? We need to know what is going to happen!!!! More, we want more episodeeees!!!!

Sincerely

Juanma and Gabriela

P.S.: Sorry for our English, but we’re learning much thanks to Heroes.
Unknown said…
I agree with everyone that this is an incredible blog, in which you can learn about the show and they way it is produced.

I hope this is also a space where fans can post their comments and those will be read by the "powers that be".

Mr. Beeman: If you ro someone from your crew has the time to read other posts in 9th wornder's website, please read this one: (I can assure you'll find it amusing and revealing).

http://www.9thwonders.com/boards/index.php?showtopic=50182&st=0&p=170728&#entry170728
hoodawg said…
I thought the gunfight scene really played into the comment Hiro made in his "goodbye" scene with Ando. The shootout was comic-book-like -- the bam/pop/boom of comic books, crazy explosions that didn't seem to fit with reality, etc. And yet, for all the apparent fakery, it almost got Hiro/Ando killed.

When Hiro turns to Ando and says "life isn't a comic book," you realize that he's finally "got it" -- even when life (or shootout scenes) seems unreal and the bizarre becomes normal, there's still real pain, death, and trouble in the world. Thus, the shootout itself the perfect matchup of Hiro's former vision of reality and his new perspective.

Not sure if that's what you were going for, but that's what I got out of it!

Thanks a ton for your insightful and detailed comments each week.
Anonymous said…
this was a terrific episode and your visual choices were spot on. i especially like the "swing and tilt" lens, it really made the two scenes with sylar quietly unsettling. your enthusiasm for your craft on this blog, and the commentary for that matter["Flat space!" :)), are great to read. thanks for allowing us fans this inside look!

xx
Jeff's Place said…
Thanks once again for a great episode!

I LOVED the fire fight and seeing most of it from Hiro and Ando's POV.
It was just neat!

I must say that I can't wait to see what happens at the Bennett house!! :)

Keep up the GREAT work!
Unknown said…
Strangely enough, while watching that Ando/Hiro/gunfight scene, I had a flashback to the old Star Wars scenes with the two droids walking through the Stormtrooper/Rebel shootout and not getting a scratch on their shiny finish. It worked for me as a balance between the tension of the dangerous moment and the lightness of two sympathetic everymen who are just struggling to follow their path.

The only real visual problem I had through the entire episode is that it felt like we zoomed in on Dale's corpse one too many times. I couldn't help but feel a sense of "yes, we got it, moving on."

All in all, it was an exceptionally well-done episode. But don't let all our praise let you get lazy. We're loving the show, and those of us who tuned in from the beginning or who showed up to the party late just hope it keeps up with the bar you've helped set.

Keep making them, and we'll keep watching them. :)

Cheers!
Matt Schuster said…
One of my favorite episodes so far and the ending left me chomping at the bit for more. My wife had to miss the episode and asked me to explain it. I told her there was no way, you have to watch the tape.

Personally, I felt the Hiro/Ando gunfight scene worked really well. Focusing on them hiding reinforced the comedic framework of Hiro's scenes.
Anonymous said…
Like a lot of the others, I enjoyed watching the gunfight scene through Hiro and Ando rather than actually watching the fight, which we've seen a thousand times before. Whether or not you did what Jeph wanted, I thought it was successful.

The flying scene I thought was a homage to Chris Reeve/Richard Donner. You didn't mention that, though, so I guess not.
Anonymous said…
Hi, Greg. There's a bit of confusion as to whether Peter invoked Hiro's power to slow/stop time when The Haitian shot him with the taser. Since you directed this one, would you be willing to say whether this is the case or not? It'd be very appreciated.
Laura said…
Absolutely awesome blog! Thank you for sharing your directorial style. I dug it and it was REALLY helpful to us burgeoning artists. :)

Bravo!
Laura
david said…
I was actually surprised by the quality of Peter's flight scene, considering that this is network TV. I loved how he has speed bursts while flying (nice throwback to Nathan's sonic boom moment). It's a unique way to show flying and it looks great!
Anonymous said…
Although I totally expect that Dale would die, I'm a little bit disappointed that the writers didn't come up with a little bit of struggle showcasing her superhearing ability to try to stop/anticipate Sylar from killing her. One thing viewers would want to see is how the heroes matchup their abilities to another. But all in all, I love Heroes! Keep up the good work!
Anonymous said…
I personally loved the episode and thought it was one of the best in the season. I have thought that some of the last few episodes left me wanting more from them. Not in a OMG i can't wait for the next ep but in a they really could have done more in this one way. Unexpected was awesome all the way around!

I just have one minor issue with it and i didn't even think of it during the ep it was after while reading the comments left in this blog. Milo/Peter was not only able to stop time and cause the prongs to drop but then he flew off the building. My issue is that this was done with the Haitian standing right there, infact he shot one of the stun guns. How was Milo/Peter the only one in the show that can use his abilities infront of the Haitian?

Maybe this was explained and i went to the bathroom or something but i'd like to know. Trust me, if the answer was "whoops" i'd still watch every Monday! One of the best shows on TV.

Keep up the good work
Avi said…
Wow, this blog is great. Apparently there's a lot more to directing than holding the camera. :)

And STAN LEE!!! WOO!!! First George Takei, than Stan The Man himself!! Like, the god of comics. Masi gets to act with the coolest people. How about Bill Shatner next? It's all about the Star Trek.
Avi said…
PS last anonymous person I think teh Hatian only negates other people's mind powers, such as Matt and Eden.
ArimalkaStarr said…
Hello, Mr. Beeman! This is my first time posting a comment on your blog, and I have to agree with the others who have said that this was one of the best episodes so far. I want to thank you for taking the time to write about all of the creative efforts that go into making the show. Your comments are truly enlightening! I want to go to film school when I get out of high school, and I’m particularly interested in cinematography, so this blog was great for me. I do agree that the swing and tilt lens was over-used in this episode. The Sylar/Dale/Mohinder scenes were just a case of trying to do too much, and in some shots, the odd focus was just not appropriate. I loved all of the Claude/Peter scenes – the green and blue tones were just beautiful, the editing always fit the “feel” of the scene, and both actors gave exceptional performances. Overall, this was an excellent episode. I loved your commentary for it as well, and I hope to hear more from you soon! =)
-Sarah Horwitz
Unknown said…
Once again, a fantastic blog entry that really helps us see into your personal creative presence and the show in general. I REALLY appreciate the time you spend on these blog entries, and thank you for making me geek out over the flight bluescreen photos. 8-)

I've just watched the preview clips for the next episode on the NBC site and it looks like one of the best so far!

Again, THANK YOU for involving us, the fans, in your creative process and posting the backstage photos too. The reason this show works so well is the attention to detail and careful direction that you and the rest of the cast and crew work so hard at, and of course Tim's ability (power? haha) to keep this whole series grounded in reality so that it's truly a believable world.

THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU! 8-)
Maquetes said…
HI, MY NAME IS EDUARDO
I´M FROM BRAZIL.
(SORRY MY BAD INGLISH)

WELL, I LIKE TO MAKE A SUJETION:
A PARTICIPATION OF THE TOM WELLING AS CLARK CANT ON HEROES END (CORSE) A PARTICIPATION OF THE HEROES ON SMALLVILLE TOO.
COULD BE SUPER!!!
THINK IN IT PLEASE!
Sus said…
..."and I didn’t have the tech support I needed to get the blog online. (i.e. I have a very limited knowledge of computers..."

I hear ya! *lol* I'm a photographer first and computer geek last! I've been on Blogger for over a year and am still trying to figure out how everything works.

Anyway...thanks for an excellent TV show. The cinematography, the actors/characters, storyline, all are top notch. Plus it's an added bonus to be able to watch Christopher Eccleston on American TV!!

Susan - Albuquerque, NM
Sarah said…
Yet another amazing look into the life of a wicked crazy TV show.

I love all the pictures you post in these, by the way. They're like the little bonuses at the end for those who are obsessed enough with Heroes and filming to read the entry the whole way though. :P

Keep up the awesome work!
Slippy Lane said…
Wow, what an insight. And hey, IMHO, Hiro and Ando worked. If you knew the kind of analysis the bullet scene has provoked over at SuperHiro.org, you'd think we were all nuts.
The thing is, I don't think you CAN be inappropriately or overly comedic with Hiro - his character is so innocent and wondrous that he can't fail to make a beautiful contrast with the darker scenes. I don't claim to have a technical understanding of the lenses or shots use, but it worked for me, and funny moments from other characters were not missed!
Unknown said…
Swing & tilt! Sing it with me - swing & tilt!

You're fantastic, Beeman, and the show is a sensational success. Congratulations, and tell everyone in the production that they have done an amazing job and changed the television landscape for the better. Thank you so much!

Jemiah at Dark Horse Comics
Anonymous said…
ok, u r great!! I loved last episode, th eone with you and Ted(don't know real name) and Hayden and HRG, and evryone else. The show rocks, no matter who writes it!
Anonymous said…
Love the show!

Any chance you could inform us of the name of the song (or the artist) that was playing on the iPod when we found Dale had been murdered?

THANKS!
Anonymous said…
thanks for your words greg. as a fellow artist in the biz, i so relate to the journey you describe. as much as certain scenes turn out magically, there are others we wish we could spend a whole day perfecting. but somehow, we have to allow ourselves to move on to the next shot. your episodes are beautifully executed. i hope to work with you someday.

best wishes, jenny

*shameles plug - www.reelaccess/talent/jennylevine.com
Anonymous said…
ethank you nice sharing

cep program
Anonymous said…
WoW shares many wow gold of its features with previously launched games. Essentially, you battle with wow gold cheap monsters and traverse the countryside, by yourself or as abuy warhammer goldteam, find challenging tasks, and go on to higher aoc gold levels as you gain skill and experience. In the course of your journey, you will be gaining new powers that are increased as your skill rating goes up. All the same, in terms of its features and quality, that is a ture stroy for this.WoW is far ahead of all other games of the genre the cheapest wow gold game undoubtedly is in a league of its own and buy cheap wow gold playing it is another experience altogether.

Even though WoW is a Cheap Wow Gold rather complicated game, the controls and interface are done in warhammer gold such a way that you don't feel the complexity. A good feature of the game is that it wow power leveling does not put off people with lengthy manuals. The instructions game4power.com cannot be simpler and the pop up tips can help you start playing the game immediately. If on the other hand, you need a detailed manual, the instructions are there for you to World Of Warcraft Gold access. Buy wow gold in this site,good for you.

<>buy wow gold
buy gold wow
cheapest wow gold .
Reklam said…
"Episode 16: Unexpected"

Greg Beeman Thanks..
Unknown said…
Your blog is so excellent that I like it very much, you must be good at writing. And what do you think of cheap polo men t shirts, I think they are are very chic, especially the cheap polo t shirts, I love them very much.
polo t shirts
discount polo t shirts
polo t shirts on sale
polo t shirts cheap
cheap polo mens shirts
polo t shirts women
polo t shirts for women
polo shirts on sale
discount polo shirts
men's polo t shirt
polo men t shirts
Cam Mozaik said…
Kaliteli ve özveriden ödün vermeyen Türkiye'de tek 50 yıllık garanti veren tek cam mozaik firması Best of the best blog tenks admin
VPS said…
Sorunsuz Güvenilir Hosting'in tek adresi sahhosting.com
Best of the best Power blog . Tenks admin
cam mozaik said…
Türkiyenin en kaliteli cam mozaik firması Türkiye'de tek 50 yıllık garanti veren tek cam mozaik firması Best of the best
blog tenks admin
Unknown said…
Ed hardy streak of clothing is expanded into its wholesale ED Hardy chain so that a large number of fans and users can enjoy the cheap ED Hardy Clothes range easily with the help of numerous secured websites, actually, our discount ED Hardy Outlet. As we all know, in fact Wholesale Ed Hardy,is based on the creations of the world renowned tattoo artist Don Ed Hardy. Why Ed hardy wholesale? Well, this question is bound to strike the minds of all individuals. Many people may say cheap Prada shoes is a joke, but we can give you discount Prada Sunglasses , because we have authentic Pradas bags Outlet. Almost everyone will agree that newest Pradas Purses are some of the most beautiful designer handbags ( Pradas handbags 2010) marketed today. Now we have one new product: Prada totes. The reason is simple: fashion prohibited by ugg boots, in other words, we can say it as Cheap ugg boots or Discount ugg boots. We have two kinds of fashionable boots: classic ugg boots and ugg classic tall boots. Ankh Royalty--the Cultural Revolution. Straightens out the collar, the epaulette epaulet, the Ankh Royalty Clothing two-row buckle. Would you like to wear Ankh Royalty Clothes?Now welcome to our AnkhRoyalty Outlet. And these are different products that bear the most famous names in the world of fashion, like Ankh Royalty T-Shirt, by the way-Prada, Spyder, Moncler(Moncler jackets,or you can say Moncler coats, Moncler T-shirt, Moncler vest,and you can buy them from our discount Moncler outlet), GHD, ED Hardy, designer Sunglasses, Ankh Royalty, Twisted Heart.
Unknown said…
NewStreetFashion
Ed Hardy
stylish design
Ed Hardy Wholesale
fashion excellent quality
wholesale Ed Hardy
ED Hardy clothing bring you a super surprise!
ed hardy wholesale clothing
The quality is so good
christian audigier
Young and creative style
abercrombie and fitch
You can have a look at it.
abercrombie & fitch
cam mozaik said…
Thanks a lot! I am just learning Information of Subject.
Php and this was very easy to follow and helped a lot.
You really took time to explain every little bit.
Thanks again Mr Beeman.
Unknown said…
I have learned more after read your article,welcome to see our websit:
http://buy-ed-hardys.com/edhardys/
Unknown said…
Young and creative style
abercrombie and fitch
You can have a look at it.
abercrombie & fitch
if you really want it
jordan 8
jordan 9
jordan 10
luck said…
uggs clearance (2) car sales. 3. "Consumer Reports" ratings. Although some models have a very long history, has many loyal fans, such as the Volkswagen Jetta (picture quotation parameters Forum), but the facelift to the present, many models it is almost just a change of face, and not with the quality of the vehicle development and improve the car, Uggs Outlet but look old and outdated. Here let us look at the foreigners in this assessment: "A nine worst U.S. Forbes assessment models.classic short ugg boots"Note: The following models are the U.S. version, with domestic sales model specifications may vary. U.S. data from MSN, Forbes and Consumer Reports ugg boots clearance.ti